Everyone once in a while something comes up where my help may actually be accepted and used, rather than being passed off and ignored.
I hear that you got put in a hard place this weekend, where you had not choice, but to listen to S1 talking negatively about Shae. Im sorry you had to go through that. I hope you wont have anything else like that to deal with, but it probably isnt the last time that will happen.
Heres the deal kiddo:
Shae loves S1 and S1 loves Shae.
Shae knows that S1 is creating a foundation for the rest of her life as an adult. From Shaes point of view, she just wants S1 to have the smoothest transition into adulthood and wants S1 to take advantage of the experiences Shae had at that time in her life.
The thing is that from S1s point of view, shes an adult and part of being almost 20 is that she knows for a fact that in all things, she knows best. So Shae wants S1 to make decisions based on both of their experiences and S1 wants to make completely independent decisions. This causes conflict and S1 has to vent. She cant vent to Shae, because S1 doesnt want to have her mind changed and Shae will use logic to try and help S1.
Because S1 was living in Shaes home, in S1s mind, Shae became the controlling parent figure. Think about how much as S1 drove you crazy when shed poking around in your business or telling you how to do anything. That is probably what S1 has been feeling.
The good news is that S1 and Shae will eventually grow beyond their current issues. Most likely this will be after S1 has had more time to get used to being an adult and realizes that sometimes it really sucks.
While it isnt nice or pretty, S1 is growing up and she is learning how to be an adult. Shell make some mistakes and if shes like most of the people Ive known (including me) shell make some pretty big mistakes while shes learning. Some things you just have to learn the hard way. It isnt the same things for everyone, but everyone has to learn something the hard way.
Shae knows that life is too short to be able to make all the possible mistakes yourself and wishes that S1 would let her point out some of the things that could make things hard.
So know that they love you and each other. That isnt going to change, even if they get to a point where they have a hard time being in the same room. Most likely, you and S1 will have some friction like this too. At least thats how its been for all of my siblings. It seems like as someone gets to the beginning of adulthood, they start having trouble getting along with whichever sibling is older and closest in age to them. As the oldest, I got to push against my parents, but Brother1 HATED me for quite a while. Brother1 drove Brother2 crazy. Brother2 used to drive Claire NUTS and Claire does the same thing to RugRat. It is the circle of family and on the positive side, you have two sisters, so youll always have at least one to talk with.
Anyway, Im guessing you may have stopped reading already, but in case you havent. Keep your chin up Kiddo!
RedJen