On my way into work the other morning, I heard discussion on the radio of the unrest and riots happening in Paris. One of the speakers kept insisting that it was time for the government to step up and take the proper action to provide for their citizens and save their lives.
I expect to hear the announcement of France's unconditional surrender to the rioting teenagers at any time now.
For a government so steeped in far reaching colonization, they have yet to consider how each new culture colonized creates a change in the cultural identity of the French as a whole. They go into an area selling togetherness and the joy of being French, but after the sale if over, where does it leave the people?
All over the world, you can find people who embrace that their culture was changed with the addition of French colonization. French-Algerians and French-Canadians are only two examples. The French bring in culture in the form of education, art and government. They insist that to be French is to be the highest form of life. In many cases, after arranging for their continued consulting fee to be sent back to Paris, the French appoint someone to keep an eye on things and the rest go back to France, where they are hailed as heroic missionaries. They have brought culture to the savages. Not that the savages will ever fully understand the gift they have been given, for they are so new and it will take generations before the children will comprehend the true divinity of being French.
The French Constitution claims that all French are equal. This equality extends to all colors, religious creeds and place of birth. No one can deny that claim. It is in the practice of such a lofty ideal that problems begin to emerge.
When faced with challenges of discrimination (racial, sex, religious), the United States acted to measure and assess the problem in society as a whole. It may not have been fast and it surely wasn’t pretty, but it happened. Statistics are routinely gathered to help behaviorists to identify and predict areas of discontent. Armed with this knowledge, the non-discrimination laws can be enforced in an effort to prevent that type of activity from spreading.
To be being color-blind simply means that everyone deserves a chance to make their own first impression. It is the same manner of thinking that has prompted much of our judicial system to be run on the premises of “innocent until proven guilty”.
Justice is always pictured blind and holding a scale to weigh the evidence. She is not blind to the evidence, only to face of the accused person. Justice makes no assumptions based on appearance, any evidence pointing to physical appearance can be identified, but prior to that, the size, shape, color, dress, stature of the one accused has nothing to do with determining the outcome.
(Back to the original topic France)
The French government looks upon polls that include racial statistics as vulgar and refuse to do so. In fact to do such a survey would be something that only the dirty Americans would do. So the problem is locked in a closet and ignored. But the problems of racial unrest and feelings of being a second class citizen grow and flourish when ignored and kept away from the light. They grow stronger and larger until the day when not only do they break out from the closet, but start to break the society that ushered them into the closet to grow.
In Paris, the unrest has spilled into the streets and across 163 towns. Over 2,000 people have been arrested in less then 2 weeks as the police try to curb the violence. Knowing the ethnic breakdown of the groups of rioters could shed much light on what sparked off the violence. That type of information could help the French government rebuild relationships with its own people. I only hope that the idea of stooping to the level of dirty/vulgar Americans to find their answers does not cause them to choke on their baguettes.
If you don’t know who is hurting, how can to give them comfort? Until you know who has been injured and how it affects their lives, you cannot effectively treat the cause.
I’m sure some in the French government look upon the riots as the problem and they will look no further. But in truth the riots are just a symptom of a much larger problem that will not be fixed overnight. Societal discrimination and prejudice happen over generations of mistrust and miscommunication. The seeds for these riots have been growing in a dark closet for decades and now there is an arsenal of hate and distrust on both sides. If the world is lucky, France will find a way to expand the idea of who is truly French to include all their citizens, even if it means taking some guidance from the hard learned lessons of dirty Americans.
France now faces a war in which they cannot surrender. This war is in the social fabric that they have created. Without abandoning the je ne sais quoi that is at the core of Paris, the French will have to find a new way or their legacy of colonization will lead to their own exile.