Cal education secretary urged to step down over remarks to child
Posted on Thu, Jul. 08, 2004 by Michael R. Blood (Associated Press)
LOS ANGELES - California Education Secretary Richard Riordan is facing calls for his ouster, and others for forgiveness, after he told a child at a library her name meant "stupid dirty girl." The remark also posed a political quandary for the man who appointed him, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Riordan, the wealthy former Los Angeles mayor known for his support of public schools, startled even friends last week with the comments at a Santa Barbara library. Schwarzenegger, his longtime friend, called Riordan's statement to the girl "unacceptable in any context" but gave no hint that his job was in danger.
But the issue hasn't gone away. In an editorial Thursday, The Sacramento Bee said "California shouldn't have an education secretary who makes offensive, damaging remarks to young children for no apparent reason."
And Alice Huffman, president of the California State Conference of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, said Riordan "is not suitable to lead education in our state."
"He's the governor's top person on education, which means we would expect him to have some love and respect for children," Huffman said. "I think he is the wrong man for the job. There is no way for him to explain this away."
The conversation, videotaped by KEYT-TV, took place Thursday at a promotional event for summer reading at Santa Barbara's central library. The girl, 6-year-old Isis D'Luciano, asked Riordan if he knew that her name meant "Egyptian goddess."
Riordan replied, "It means stupid dirty girl."
After nervous laughter in the room, the girl again told Riordan the meaning of her name.
"Hey, that's nifty," he said.
A day later, Riordan issued a statement that said he "teased" the girl. "I immediately apologized to her and I want to do so again for the misunderstanding," Riordan said.
Riordan, a venture capitalist who started a foundation supporting literacy, has a reputation for awkward - some might say insensitive - remarks and behavior. As mayor, he once greeted hunger strikers outside his office eating a hamburger. In a speech to the Association of California School Administrators earlier this year, he told a story about a nun physically disciplining a student that startled some in the audience.
State Assemblywoman Jackie Goldberg, a Democrat who served on the Los Angeles City Council when Riordan was mayor, called the remarks to the girl "completely reprehensible" but said they were uncharacteristic for a man with a soft touch for children.
"I've been in dozens of situations with him with children - he's usually the grandfatherly guy," Goldberg said. "I've seen him say things he wished he could take back many times - but never around kids."
Asked Thursday if Schwarzenegger had 100 percent confidence in Riordan's leadership, his office did not respond directly but released a statement from last week. The governor's chief spokesman, Rob Stutzman, told reporters in Sacramento later that Riordan had not been asked to resign and, "That's the end of the issue, as far as we are concerned."
The girl's mother, Trinity Lila of Goleta, said her daughter was fine and she considered the issue over.
"Obviously it hurt her feelings but she didn't take it personally. She knew he was wrong and she let it go," Lila said. "I'm not going to sue them for therapy bills."
"He's already apologized repeatedly," Lila added. Although Riordan's office has tried to contact her, "I don't see what else is to be done."
At a time when Schwarzenegger has been trying to push his budget through the Legislature - it's already more than a week overdue - the Riordan controversy has been an unwelcome distraction. A group of civil rights organizations, including the NAACP, planned to protest Riordan's remarks at the Capitol Thursday.
But the organizer, state Assemblyman Mervyn Dymally, D-Los Angeles, canceled it after an apparent mix-up over the girl's racial background.
Dymally was quoted in the San Jose Mercury News Thursday saying the child was "a little African-American girl. Would he (Riordan) have done that to a white girl?"
The girl is Caucasian, with blond hair.
Dymally did not return telephone calls. His office issued a statement Wednesday calling Riordan's remarks to the girl "outrageous and irresponsible" but issued a statement under the Assemblyman's name Thursday saying, "To err is human; to forgive is divine."
"Race is not a factor in this issue," Dymally said, adding that Riordan had apologized a second time. "It is time for us to move on."
But Huffman, the NAACP executive, said in a statement, "It is abusive to use such language toward a child, regardless the gender, race, socioeconomic background or national heritage."
Schwarzenegger should "remove Mr. Riordan," she added.
My Comments: